Friday, 28 August 2020

Book 4, Letter 11 Eulogy for Peter Max Taubert









Never say of anything, “I have lost it,” but, “I have restored it.” Has your child died? They are restored. Has your wife died? She is restored.”

Enchiridion of Epictetus – Section XII


Has my father died? He has been restored to the place from which he came.


It is better for sons to bury fathers, than for fathers to bury sons.

Herodotus of Halicarnassus – Histories Book 1


I am honoured to have this privilege. I am proud to restore my father to the earth.




Everyone knew a different version of Peter, I am sure of it, so there could be no more fitting epitaph than for every single one of us to tell a story about him. I cannot hope to truly sum up the life of a seventy three year old man, so please forgive me if I emphasise some details, and omit others. This is a speech, not a biography.


I remember him singing in the morning over breakfast. I remember him singing in the kitchen over dinner. I remember the spoonerisms, and word games and camping in the backyard, camping in the bush, rifle shooting, bow shooting.


I remember the good and the bad.


I remember voicing a silent protest throughout my teens, confused and hurt by all I had seen during my parents divorce. I did not speak to him for, six years I think. Later, I remember him at my wedding day, proud as punch. I remember him when my son was born, beaming like the sun. I remember him when my marriage fell apart, he was solid as a rock and always ready with hot food and a glass of wine whenever I needed it. Through later breakdowns he gave my son and I a place in his home when we needed it.


He opened his home and his heart to us.


I remember his prejudices, and his foolish opinions, and his stubborn ideas, and I fought him on nearly every one, and still we found a way to listen to each other, to hear each other, and to offer respect instead of reproach. I saw him grow and change as a man, I saw him reliquish unjustifyable prejudices, I saw him soften with old age. I saw the relationship he built with his Grandson, Wren, a relationship that shaped and transformed both of them. He honoured the boy, conversed with him, offered advice and listened when it was given back. Wren dubbed him Dragon Pete, and for seven years the name has stuck. We three dined together, gardened together, watched a lot of movies together, we even travelled together to visit Philip and Sandra for Dad & Sandra's seventieth birthdays.


Half Man, Half Dragon. Everyone knew him differently, but there he was, living his life and blazing with a personal vigour that has inspired my own ceaseless efforts to live a life worth remembering. He believed in happiness, and despite struggling with crippling depression, was never one to dismiss an opportunity to enjoy life's grand and ordinary moments. His collection of Black Dog figurines was forever proudly on display, on the shelf that held all his books on mythology. There is no coincidence in this.


Not all my memories are complete, a lot are fragmentary. I remember Dad's suicide attempt, and his stay in hospital. I remember the terrible fights he had with mum, I remember the police being called, more than once, I remember being taken to the police station to get away, along with my sisters and my mother, more than once. I remember the night my parents marriage really ended. It was violent, confusing, noisy, frightening.


My memories are fragmentary just as our knowledge of Peter is fragmentary. I may be his son, but there are many who knew him far better than I, and for decades longer. I got to know him best in his last two decades. I witnessed his maturation into his twilight years. I got to know him as all his years of experience: trauma and love, came back to him, and I saw him trying to deal with everything that he was as a man. I saw him trying to reconcile his past, in himself. In his last year he really opened up to me, and as he remembered fragments of his childhood, he would share them with me. A lot of what came back to him were terrible memories, and I listened to him, just letting him get the stories out, but a lot more stories were joyful, or funny, or ordinary, and I would listen to him reminisce about his hunting days, or about the cars he had owned, the jobs he worked, or the places he had taught, or lectured, or sold books. We would look through old photo albums and he would tell me the exact model of camera he used for each era of photography, from his first Box Brownie, to his most modern digital cameras. His prized photographs still sit on bookshelves.


I remember the feasts, I remember him serving six different prawn dishes at one New Years eve party. There were gigantic bowls of salad, wine breathing in carafe's upon the mantle piece, whiskey in the freezer. Champagne for every toast. I remember his dark study with books lining every wall, and a cabinet with curiosities, like an antique store. He would smoke cigars and type, and I would sit beside him, just reading whatever he was writing. As a child I sat and watched him write his 'History of German U-Boat Warfare', and then in later years, I watched him write and publish the first edition of his food additives book, then I saw him publish the second edition.

I remember him with my Uncle Gabor (not a blood relative, but a relative by choice). They would eat weisswurst and polish sausage and salads,olives and fruit, and they would drink wine and talk and talk and talk and listen to music, and drink more wine and talk for days on end. I learned the art of friendship, watching them.



I remember the stories he told most often, the things from his life that he was most proud of:


Going through teachers college, studying field botany and writing his book about Folk Lore and the Weather. Many hunting stories, digging cars out of axle deep mud, shooting five goats with five bullets, or was it four bullets? His book tours and all the lectures he gave, the people he met and the lives he influenced. He was proud of teaching himself how to use the AUTOCAD architectural design program, and of his time at TAFE, teaching computing and welding. He had some complaints about his working life, but ultimately he was proud of everything he achieved. He lived to his own standard, to his own work ethic, and he was justified in his confidence. He was a capable man; capable of learning, and of perfecting his work. He worked with his hands and with his mind and with his voice, at each stage of his life applying himself wholly to whatever tasks he set for himself.


Sometimes I reflect that I only knew him a relatively short time, I didn't really know him, that my memories amount to very little : but then I recall his passion for Asian food, and the absolutely incendiary curries and stir fry's he would cook. I remember Dragon Pie, the shepherds pie he baked and then decorated with an incredibly detailed picture of a dragon, drawn dot by dot with peas and corn. I remember the concrete dragon he sculpted to sit atop the chimney of the brick BBQ he also built. I remember, as a kid, the tumble-dryer warmed blankets before bed, being tucked in like a sardine, wrapped up tight in a hot blanket. I remember the corn growing in the back yard, I remember the sugar cane he smuggled home from Queensland and which he planted in the garden at Murray Bridge, and I remember watching it take root and grow. I remember motorbike rides, I remember the sail boat, and crossing Lake Alexandrina with John Gill, and I remember the Kingswood station wagon, and every time we drove home from Adelaide, Dad would ask us kids if we wanted to take the free-way, or the old road to get home, and we would all sing that we wanted the old road, even though it was ten minutes longer.


I will not, however, paint only a glowing portrait of my father, making out that he was a creature of perfect kindness and virtue. I want to acknowledge that his life was marred by some poor decisions, and by aggression born of unprocessed trauma. Yet, amidst the frightful domestic violence of our disintegrating family, my childhood memories of Dad are coloured brightly with the love he showed us, with his humour and his silly songs, his piggy back rides and his bedtime stories. I cannot paint him all black because of his faults, just as I cannot paint him all white because of his virtues. He was a human being, I need say no more. We all knew him.


He was a multicultural man, an international gentleman of discerning taste and intense intellectual passions. His book collection is diverse and fascinating. His music is the same. His movie collection, and the actors and actors database that he spent two decades building is perhaps the great monument of the work of his retirement. These collections of his, his coins, his figurines, his posters, his cinema memorabilia, his photographs, his family history, his decks of playing cards with pictures of naked girls, his Marilyn Monroe pictures...these are the arranged imprints of his fingers in the dust of the world. These collections of his are the memories made real from his life of passion.


He told me often in the last few years that he could remember very little of his childhood, and he knew that it was better that way. These mementos that fill his home are the material evidence of his efforts to build, and to hold onto, all the joyful events of his life. To preserve that which was most precious to him, and to keep it always in view. This is perhaps illustrated no better than by his fabulous love of Peter Pan. Dad was a boy who was denied a childhood, and so as an adult, he found a way, through the medium of fairy stories and mythology, to preserve the childhood self he so desired.


Twenty eight years after his divorce, he still kept a single photo of Mum on his book shelf. A photo he took of her silhouette against an apocalyptic sky, churning with the smoke of Ash Wednesday. Perhaps there is some symbolism there, but ultimately it is a beautiful picture, a work of art, and he preserved it as a reminder.


How many of us can ever say that we truly understand ourselves? Though we strive to achieve this goal our entire lives, it seems that the mystery of Self, is never truly solved. Dad had his blind spots, and he had a way of dismissing the parts of his past that he did not wish to address, or discuss. This made it very difficult for those of us that he hurt, to find resolution, or a sense of closure. His refusal to confront the mistakes he made with his family ultimately kept all of us at arms length. We each had to make a choice to forgive and forget, or else be burdened by our memories. Some mistakes he made were beyond forgiveness, and I do not reproach those who could not forgive, or forget. I know that as his son, he treated me better than he treated many others, a kindness which he also extended to his grandson, Wren.


I feel perhaps a little guilty to have known him at his kindest, to have spent the last decade dining with him, drinking with him, watching movies with him, going to the central markets, riding on trains, playing with trains, going shopping, going to the hospital, going to the doctor, following the ambulance, going to the hospital again. As hard as his medical problems were, every moment being his son, having the opportunity, the willingness and the ability to help him gave me great pride. I am grateful that he let me get close enough to be able to help him. I am grateful to have had the opportunity to love him, and to be loved by him, and to be with him till his last day.


I could go on, telling you of the love I felt for my father, and of the gratitude I feel towards him for all that he gave me, spiritually, intellectually, and practically, but my eulogising must come to an end. I will conclude with this poem, written three weeks after his death.



For my father

August 2020



Mountains in the sky

the clouds make miniature

the earth beneath their shadow


You ride white horses across mountains in the sky

another ghost rider chasing dreams through drifting memory

all the world beneath your shadow


my tiny life

my little family

my grain of sand upon the ocean floor

while you

ride horses

across mountains

in the

sky


I

rise

to see

the sunlight

upon your mighty face

and I am blessed by the memory of your voice

in my ear,

and all your songs are

my songs

now

and I will sing them

to my son

and we will play games inside our memory of you

and tell stories

and tell others,

other people,

we will tell all about you

and your courageous, complicated life

while you ride horses

across mountains

while you ride motorbikes

and run through forests

and through streets

and through our veins


and I,

this tiny grain of sand

in your palm,

all your truth and consequence

made manifest,

I am miniature in your shadow,

all the world is made small

while you

and the mountains

grow tall

and I rise

each day

to see

the sun.


Thursday, 20 August 2020

Book 4, Letter 10, to my Father. Two weeks have passed since your death.




Hey Dad,


It's Tuesday so I'm back at your place. I'm cooking the food you left for me, a chicken and corn dish which is simmering while I write. I'm drinking your wine. Wren is playing solitaire on your computer, he sings as he plays, music pouring out of him, just like it always poured out of you. The house still smells like you, my hands smell like your hands. The dust still holds your finger prints and the wine glass still holds the memory of your lips. You are here with me, in me.

I saw your next door neighbour. She said that the last time she spoke to you, perhaps a couple weeks before your death, you said to her that you were happy with your life, happy with your home.

I am happy with your life. Sitting at your kitchen table as I write, I am crying, unstoppable tears. Your wine is sweet. My grief is sweet. You gave me so much in life, and you continue to provide me with all the necessities of life. You have given me your home, the very seat of your kingdom and all the mementos I could ever ask for.

Wren and I will sit down with dinner to watch the third Pirates of the Caribbean movie. We watched the first two with you before you left us, so we have returned to finish the series, and to continue our life with you, despite your absence.

I thought I was fine. I thought my grief may have been fleeting, but of course, it will last the rest of my life. It is your lasting gift to me, this bottomless well of emotion from which I may draw. The water of your love, Dad, I will drink it deep. I will quench my thirst for life, I will live as you hoped I might live: with passion, music and love.


Thank you today. Thank you tomorrow. Thank you forever.


With gratitude and respect.


Your loving son, Morgan




PS. I have been reading the book you leant me, The Jungle and the Sky by CS Forester. There is a passage I would like to share, since it seemed you must have had this in mind when you suggested I read the book. It concerns a drummer playing his drum in a village in the jungle...


Tali had perfected the rhythm he gad been striving for. There was a neat series of beats, and then a hesitation, like a man stumbling, a recovery, and then another stumble. A man could hardly keep from laughing when he heard that rhythm. It was a good joke, something really funny, catching and captivating. The dancers were grinning with pleasure and excitement. They had formed round Tali in a semi-circle, and the dance to suit the rhythm rapidly evolved itself. They closed slowly in on him with mock tenseness and dignity. Then a sudden quick interchange of places, a backward swirl, and they were ready in the nick of time to begin the cycle again. It was an exciting and stimulating dance, amusing and yet at the same time intensely gratifying artistically. People came swarming from all points to join in, and the semi-circle grew wider and wider. Soli...leapt into the centre.

'Hey!' he shouted. 'Hey, hey, hey!'

He was up on his toes, posturing picturesquely. He reeled to one side, he reeled to the other side, while behind him the crowd neatly shifted in time with him, interchanging in a geometrical pattern vastly gratifying. Tali thumped and thundered on his drum. His eyes were staring into the vacancy over the heads of the dancers. He touched the side of the drum with his elbow to mute it, and it's tone changed from loud mirth to subtle mockery.

'Hey!' shouted the crowd.

Tali introduced a new inflexion into the rhythm. He made no break in it ; perhaps not even a metronome could have measured the subtle variation of time. But now the drumbeat told of his tragedy, of vivid drama. Soli in the centre caught the change of mood and found words for it.

'The tall tree totters!' he intoned. 'Run, men, run!'

The drum thundered, the dancers interchanged.

'Run, men, run!' roared the crowd, catching the final beats.

'It hangs upon the creepers,' sand Soli in his nasal monotone. 'Down it falls!'

Beat – beat – shuffle – shuffle.

'Down it falls!' roared the crowd... … …


Thanks for the book Dad, it's great.   I'll let you know when I finish it.






Friday, 14 August 2020

Book 4, Letter 9, Part 2 of 2 To Cicero, On the Orator


A few months ago I bought An Introduction to Roman Law, by Barry Nicholas (1962) with the expectation that its dry subject matter would help me get to sleep in the evening. Oh my foolish heart! I have seen the clock tick past midnight many times while holding this book upon my lap. I had no idea that I would find in it the same enticing stories of human trials and triumphs that excite me in many other books on history. But you know all about that don't you Cicero.


There is also another thing which makes it all the easier to learn and master the law: though most people find this hard to believe. For the fact is that legal study is so utterly fascinating and absorbing!... ...Once he has embarked upon that line, the whole range of law and our priestly chronicles and the Twelve Tables will give him a remarkable picture of what ancient times were like. For one thing, these records provide invaluable evidence about primitive linguistic usage; and, besides, some of the types of legal action they preserve are extremely informative about our ancestors' customs and ways of life. (On the Orator: Cicero)


I am always fascinated to read about the ancient people's attitudes to their own ancient past. I live in such a peculiar time (I suppose that everyone considers their own era to be peculiar...Thucidides certainly did, and I am grateful...), wait...where was I...oh yes. I am interested in both ancient history, as well as far reaching futuristic science fiction, I feel that I am living in an era subject to an equal influence between these two poles of influence. I can feel the stratified layers of history beneath my feet, and also the atmospheric pressures of speculative thinking drawing me forward.


But I wanted to talk about Roman Law....


Divorce. Since Roman marriage depended for its existence merely on the parties' living together wit the intention of being married, it could equally be brought to an end by the free will of either or both. And just as no formality was needed for the beginning of a marriage, so also none was needed for its termination...Until the later years of the Republic this total freedom of divorce was kept in check by public opinion and by the Roman habit of consulting a family council before making any important decision. ... By the last century BC, however, divorce had become a matter of course, at least among the upper classes, for whose habits alone we have any evidence. The respectable Cicero put away his wife after thirty years of marriage in favour of a young and wealthy bride, and Cato of Utica had no compunction in remarrying his divorced wife when she was left a wealthy widow by her intervening husband. ... Seneca remarks that women reckon the years not by the names of the consuls, but by those of their husbands. (An introduction to Roman Law)


It is easy to think of women's rights as being a 20th Century concept, but it seems that throughout the development of the Roman Empire, greater and greater protections were granted to women in the case of divorce, securing their social and financial security against divorce. Laws were put in place to prevent the mismanagement of a wife's dowry, and to insist on the full return of all lands owned by the wife prior to the marriage. Since children were by law, the property of the husband, upon divorce, a percentage of the dowry could be kept by the husband for the maintenance of those children, but later changes to the law under Justinian, abolished this right.


I'm not particularly interested in divorce law, other than that is bears relevance to my own life. My parents divorced in 1992 when I was twelve years old, and my mother was shunned by the Catholic Church to which she had belonged for most of her life. As a child I was subject to visitation laws, as well as the problems of a restraining order put out against my father, preventing him from stepping foot on the same street as my mother's house. Along with my two sisters, I had to walk with my bags to the end of the street to be picked up by my father for weekend visits. My father had been violent towards my mother, so I understand her fears, and the reason for the restraining order, but I also remember the shame and confusion I felt each time I walked with my bags in hand to meet my father, waiting in the car.


Of course, my mother possessed no dowry, but there were child support payments, and the division of mutually held property, and for five years my parents struggled through family court, with many fights and accusations.


I have been lucky, or perhaps I just learned the lessons from my parents divorce, that since separating from my own first wife, we have maintained a 50/50 split of custody of our son, and have shared the expenses of his upbringing. My marriage was like the Roman custom, in that it was a marriage not sanctioned by any government documentation, but rather a mutual agreement. We were in fact re-married each year on the 31st of October in a private Handfasting ceremony, which for us meant a promise to remain together for a year and a day. We continued in this way for seven years before our promises came to an end. Our initial Handfasting Ceremony was presided over by a pagan priestess, and took place on a Sunday in the middle of a public marketplace in a small country town. Our friends and family gathered in a circle around us to witness the ceremony, which took less than five minutes. Afterwards we shared a potluck feast with everyone present, we drank mead, we danced to a funk band that showed up uninvited, we were entertained by a belly dancer friend, and the children were thrilled by the performance of The Amazing Drumming Monkeys, a puppetry and music duo who played African drums and sang songs about eating fruit and doing monkey yoga.





I don't know why I'm telling you all of this, Cicero, but it is easy to talk freely with you, so I will not judge myself harshly for this digression. It is actually pleasant, seven years having passed since my divorce, to reminisce about our wedding day.


No one knows why you divorced your wife Terentia. People speculate that it was over a breach of trust concerning money, that your wife may have stolen from you, but really, the truth is not visible in either your letters, or in the accounts given by later historians. Your divorce from your second wife Publilia is better understood; she did not seem to approve of the doting manner of your love for your daughter, Tullia. Whatever the truth, your life, and the whole Roman Republic was a mess at the time, and bad decisions were being made by everyone. I do not judge you. Even if you only married Publilia for her money, I don't really care. You paid back the dowry when you divorced, in accordance with the law, so all's fair in love and war, I guess.


I don't know where I'm going with all this. It's just a rambling letter. Every day I read, and every day I think of things I would like to write to you about.


With gratitude and Respect


Morgan.


*

PS. I'm not your only fan...

The Oration against Catiline - read by an Australian.

https://youtu.be/NZg1PzU9fqw?list=TLPQMDkwNTIwMjDXe7-Js65O7A


Thursday, 6 August 2020

Book 4, Letter 9, Part 1 of 2, To Cicero, On the Orator

 



Dear Cicero,


Another day, the world is ending, my coffee tastes the same. My coffee tastes good. My Father died last week, the result of Diabetes, and though I am grieving as any son who loved his father would, it is not with pain or sadness, but with some new kind of agonising joy that I find myself crying. It is good that children should bury their parents, it is natural, and I am grateful to have the opportunity to live in a peaceful part of the world where this is possible. The present conditions of the pandemic prevent any sort of family gathering for a funeral, but that is not such a heartbreak as one might imagine. I have time to write the eulogy. I have time to sort through the legal and financial procedures.  I have time to grieve on my own terms.


I wrote a letter to my father, Cicero, which you may read here if you wish. 


Despite this current calamity, I have been reading your book, On the Orator, a very modern translation (2012). You come across as a little pompous, but I suppose that you are a little pompous. It seems to be the Roman habit, an ingrained belief in the absolute superiority of Romans, particularly those living in the city itself. It comes across a bit pig headed these days, like this declaration that you put in the mouth of Lucius Licinius Crassus:


Compare our laws with those of other communities; with the laws of Lycurgus and Draco and Solon. You will find them extremely easy to understand why our ancestors surpassed every other nation in the world in wisdom. For the laws of all other countries are incredibly disorderly; one might even call them ridiculous. This, however is a subject that will be familiar to you from my daily conversation, since I am always repeating how much wiser we Romans are than the Greeks and everyone else.


You lived on top of the world.


Seneca reminded me today, as he so often does, that there are not many in Rome who have achieved greatness, who were not also brought low by the same fortune that made them soar. I bring this up I suppose because I have been relinquishing my own ambitions, finding instead that contentedness with small joys, is a far better path to tread. I am content with my family and home, I am content with my music, with my art, and with my work. This contentedness is not static, rather it is lively and swept up in a great spirit of innovation. I have been spending a lot more time at home with my kids, gardening, or watching movies, reading books, playing games. There is a plague, you see. Nothing like the Athenian Plague, but still, the whole world is affected, and many people are spending a lot more time at home.


I am breathing out, and as I said, relinquishing my ambition. Holding myself up to my own impossible standards was exhausting, and ultimately defeating. My goals are always shifting, I am unable to enjoy the triumphs as I strive for recognition, as I strive for a voice in the crowded atmosphere of art, music, writing.


You didn't let go, Cicero.


You didn't let go.


Are you a brave man or a fool?


Whatever mixture of virtue and vice that you possess, you are are terrific writer. I am racing through On the Orator, laughing and reading passages to my partner, underlining all my favourite sections so that I could write about them to you.


For the fact is that there is no earthly reason why a man should limit himself to the knowledge of one art and one only. Neither nature nor statute nor usage demand any such restriction. Pericles, for example, although he was the most eloquent man in Athens, also directed its national policy for very many years...


You also make reference to the Greek physician Empedocles being a good poet, and of Socrates, not only being a master of philosophy, but also of geometry and music. I bring this up because it reminds me of a quote from another author on a similar topic.


A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects.”


― Robert A. Heinlein, from 'Time Enough for Love'


I read this book when I was about twenty years old, (I am forty now), and the above passage has subtly influenced the ebb and flow of my entire adult life. I know that the passage I quoted from you Cicero, is not quite pointed in this direction, you were making a different sort of argument, but you know how one thing leads to another, and cross disciplinary study produces unique fruits. Heinlein may have been a science fiction author, but I have long supported notion that Fiction contains as much truth as Non-Fiction, and that often the most profound philosophical maxims are best delivered through the mouths of imaginary characters.


Considering that your book, On the Orator, is a sort of philosophical/historical fiction, presented in the same manner as Plato's Socratic dialogues, or Xenophon's Cyropaedia, it seems that we are on the same page.


*


PS. I have been watching for you in the movies....


Cicero in the movie Cleopatra

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4KvR9ksDJlM